Your Website vs. AI: Winning Traffic Back in the Age of ChatGPT and Google AI

Posted by Anya Sleezer << back to blog

Last Updated on September 22, 2025

Search has changed—and not in your favor.

If your web traffic is down, it’s not just you. AI-powered tools like ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, and Microsoft Copilot are giving users direct answers—without sending them to your website. The result? Fewer clicks, less organic reach, and more competition for attention.

This shift isn’t a passing fad—it’s a fundamental rewrite of how people find and consume information online. The question now isn’t “Will AI change search?” It’s “How fast can you adapt?”

Why AI Search Is Threatening Your Website Traffic

Zero-click searches are becoming the norm. Research from SEMrush shows a sharp rise in searches where users never click a single result—because AI tools display the answer immediately.
Generative results are replacing the “10 blue links.” Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Bing AI now summarize content into conversational answers—pushing traditional results further down the page.
Your site is a source, not a destination. AI engines pull from your content but may never give the user a reason to visit your page unless you optimize to be cited and linked in those AI answers.

AI is changing the game. And the winners will be those who pivot from Search Engine Optimization (SEO) to Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) and Generative Engine Optimization (GEO).

3 Strategies to Win Back Visibility in the AI Era

1. Shift from SEO to GEO and AEO

Traditional SEO is still important—but it’s not enough

AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) ensures your content is structured for AI tools and voice assistants to use directly.
GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) helps your brand get cited inside AI-generated summaries, keeping you visible even in zero-click searches.

Action Steps:

Add structured data (FAQPage, HowTo, QAPage schema).
Use conversational headings and Q&A formats in your blogs.
Break content into clear, quotable sections AI can lift directly.

2. Create AI-Friendly, Authoritative Content

Generative AI tools prioritize clarity, authority, and depth. They’re more likely to reference pages that demonstrate E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness).

Action Steps:

Include bylines with author credentials.
Add real examples, case studies, and statistics to your content.
Use natural language and semantic variety to match AI’s parsing patterns.
Write longer, well-structured pages with in-depth coverage of topics.

3. Optimize Your Technical Foundation for AI Crawling

AI crawlers aren’t the same as Google’s traditional crawlers. Some can’t process complex JavaScript or slow-loading designs.

Action Steps:

Audit your robots.txt to ensure AI bots can access your key content.
Improve page load speeds and mobile responsiveness.
Use clean HTML with clear headings and alt text for all images.
Implement llms.txt to guide Large Language Model crawlers.

Step-by-Step Action Plan for Website Managers

Step

Run an AI-focused SEO audit
Add structured schema to top content
Rewrite key pages in Q&A format
Expand long-form authority content
Track AI visibility in analytics tools

Goal

Identify crawl issues for AI bots
Increase AI snippet inclusion
Boost AEO performance
Improve chances of AI citation
Measure impact beyond clicks

Win Back Website Traffic from AI Search

AI chatbots like ChatGPT and Google AI are rewriting the rules of search. Is your site ready?

Get our 1-Page AI Optimization Checklist — the exact steps you need to audit, structure, and future-proof your content for AI visibility.

Step-by-step action plan
Schema & structure tips
E-E-A-T signals to boost credibility

Download your free checklist now — and start reclaiming your traffic today.

Measuring Success in the AI Search Era

Don’t just track clicks—track citations. Tools like Wix AI Visibility, Peec.ai, and some enterprise SEO platforms now measure how often your site is mentioned in AI results. Even if users don’t click, citations help build brand recognition and trust.

FAQs

1. How do I know if AI is reducing my website traffic?
Monitor your organic traffic in Google Analytics and compare it to historical data. If impressions stay high but clicks drop, AI results may be intercepting visitors.

2. What’s the difference between GEO and AEO?

AEO is about structuring content for AI and voice assistants to answer questions.
GEO is about making your content more likely to be cited by AI tools in generative summaries.

3. Do traditional SEO tactics still matter?
Yes—but they must be adapted. Keywords, backlinks, and on-page SEO are still essential, but structure, clarity, and authority signals are now just as critical.

4. Can smaller websites compete in the AI era?
Yes. AI tools value clarity and authority over domain size. Niche expertise, structured formatting, and quality data can help small sites win citations.

5. What’s the first thing I should do right now?
Audit your most important pages for AI readability—make sure they’re structured, conversational, and authoritative, with schema markup in place.

Don’t Compete with AI—Partner with It

AI isn’t going away. The brands that thrive will be those that adapt their websites for both humans and machines—providing value, clarity, and structure that AI tools want to share.

At Levo, we help brands like yours win back visibility, clicks, and customers in the AI search era—without guesswork.

Book your free 30-minute consult › and let’s future-proof your website today.

Anya Sleezer

Anya Sleezer is the owner of Levo, a full–service marketing agency, focused on helping companies from all industries who are concerned with their marketing results, traffic, branding, advertising, or websites.

<< back to blog

Services

TAKE US FOR A TEST DRIVE.

We understand that representing your ideas, your solutions and your brand is a big responsibility. Try our 30-min, complimentary phone consultation, where you'll discover if we're a good fit for your needs, gain project clarity quickly and easily, and save valuable time

Book Free Consult